Saturday, March 8, 2003
by Alex Berenson
The number is the quarterly earnings figure that CEOs and top managers of public companies die for, at least in the career sense. Mr. Berenson, a leading U.S. business reporter, tells how investors' expectations of rising earnings were fed by the collusion of institutional money managers, accountants, stock analysts and company executives. His story sparkles with good sense, wonderful insights into the corruption of securities markets and good writing.
"The last and greatest bull market of the twentieth century started on a warm and muggy August Tuesday in New York in the summer of 1982," he writes. "Investors wanted a clear signal that inflation had been beaten.." He traces the market's surge in the remainder of the year to a pronouncement from Henry Kaufman, dubbed Dr. Doom for his persistently pessimistic views, that interest rates would drop below 10 per cent.
Investors' taste for growth was whetted. Through the 1980s and the 1990s, with time out for the crash of Oct. 10, 1987 and a few nasty moments in the Gulf War in 1991 and the Asian currency crisis of 1998, the market steamed ahead, fed by accountants' willingness to collaborate with companies' pumping up their bottom lines. The accountants - and not just the late Arthur Andersen - were usually not indicted coconspirators. It all came to a screeching halt in the three year bear market in which, just as in the 1930s, the wolves of retribution began to haunt Wall Street.
Mr. Berenson parcels out guilt for the fall beyond accountants. He points to investment analysts working for brokers who willingly or stupidly went along with the deceit in exchange for immense investment banking fees. Also guilty were institutional investors who lapped up deceits that fitted nicely with their heavily hyped growth strategies and and private investors who pursued the grail of earnings ignorant of their peril.
Mr. Berenson tells the story of the lust for earnings with scholarship and style. The Number will be one of the best business books and surely the most readable accounting book of the year. For investors who want to know why their Xerox almost went under and why Enron did, this is gripping stuff. For everyone else, just a great read.